Prices of natural gas in Europe could go even higher


Peter Zeihan

Geopolitical Strategist
Archive |

Now that Russia has cut off natural gas pipelines to Europe, and Europe is trying to fill its storage facilities for the winter, they’re going to have to rely on buying natural gas in the liquified form at much higher prices. Around 40 tankers with chilled gas worth billions of dollars are sitting off the coasts of Europe and Asia, figuring if they wait until it gets colder, they can unload their fuel at higher prices. Straight Arrow News contributor Peter Zeihan says Europeans have two choices: continue buying on the spot market or decrease demand.

Excerpted from Peter’s Nov. 22 “Zeihan on Geopolitics” newsletter:

The War in Ukraine has proven disastrous for Europe’s dwindling energy supply. Now that Europe has lost its primary source of natural gas – Russia – they’re paying up to 10x market price to replace that lost supply.

So what can Europe do? First, hope that they have one of the warmest winters on record. After that, they only have two (equally detrimental) options. One, continue sourcing natural gas from spot markets or two, remove the demand for natural gas. I didn’t say the options were great, but at least they have choices.

Hello, everybody from Chile, Colorado. I thought this was a great time to talk about winter in Europe. Now the Europeans have lost their primary source of natural gas from Russia. And what they’ve been doing to this point is paying about ten times market price in order to fill up their storage. 

The problem is that storage is just that, storage. It’s not even an emergency supply, it’s part of their normal supply system for the winter. So stuff comes in via pipe, and in the summer, demand is lower, and then in the winter, they get about two-thirds of their supply from pipe and about 1/3 from storage. 

Well, they’ve lost half of the stuff that used to come in from pipe from the Russians. So they’re going to be drawing down more aggressively. 

Next winter is going to be really ugly for Europe. And by the time we get to next winter, it’s going to be really ugly, because the pipes from Russia are in many cases now destroyed. And so they’re not going to be able to top off their storage at all without paying absolutely exorbitant prices. 

Now, there are a couple of ways that you can kind of square the circle here. The first one is bring in natural gas from new sources. Now the pipes are all maxed out. So that has to be with liquefied form. 

Normally natural gas is transported by pipe through fixed infrastructure. But you can, at the point of export, freeze the stuff into a liquid, and then load it onto a specialized tanker that then brings it into your consuming zone where it is offloaded, and re-gasified and then funneled back into your system normally. 

Now, freezing a gas into a liquid form is as energy-intensive and as expensive as you might think. The Europeans get around that on the emission side by pretending that anything that happens with natural gas before it reaches Europe is not their problem, which is, you know, very par for the course when it comes to European data on carbon. And in terms of energy security, unless you sign a fixed-term contract, that’s usually ten or twenty years, you’re tapping what’s called the spot market. So just individual cargoes that are looking for a home, those tend to be far more expensive. 

And the Europeans don’t want to commit to 20 years of natural gas from a source on the other side of the planet. So they’re trying to just have the spot market almost exclusively. And they’re having to pay the price for that. And that is part of the reason why European inflation is so much stronger in many cases than it is even in the United States. 

So that’s option one. They’ve been doing a lot of that. Option number two is to shut down demand, whether it’s demand destruction, or purposefully shutting things down, doesn’t really matter. The Europeans have chosen to largely remove natural gas from their industrial space. And so we are seeing huge amounts of industrial closures across the entire industrial space. And this has a lot of consequences. 

So the Germans, for example, don’t think of energy in the way that most Americans do. We’re very agnostic about where we get our energy – so Mexico, Canada, Saudi Arabia, Venezuela, if we don’t think anyone is looking. The Germans need long-term contracts with state-owned suppliers, through fixed infrastructure, so they have a degree of stability in their supply. That is not an option right now, because a lot of the pipes are offline. 

So when you shut down industrial infrastructure in demand in Germany, you’re talking about something that cuts to the core of their entire industrial model. Because that natural gas isn’t just part of their electricity system, it’s part of their petrochemical system, which is what makes their  manufacturing sector possible. So in shutting all this stuff down, the Europeans are choosing, maybe not consciously, but they are choosing a general deindustrialization trend for the entire continent.  

No one is making nitrogen-based fertilizer in Europe anymore. No one is smelting aluminum anymore. A lot of the steel foundries are shutting down, auto manufacturers already down by a quarter and is dropping fast. It’ll be gone in less than a year, because remember, next year, they’re gonna have even less to work with. 

So we are looking at the collapse of not just the broader European economic model, but the specific German industrial model that allows things like BMWs to exist. 

The problem they’re facing this winter is that even the normal backup plan of going to the United States for liquefied natural gas is not really an option. As you can see, it’s a little chilly here in Colorado, it’s chilly in Washington, it is chilly in Texas and Florida. Here, it’s four degrees this morning. 

And if it’s cold in the United States, that means we need incrementally more natural gas in order to keep the heat on. And the only swing energy producer that the United States has in terms of power generation is natural gas. Coal is baseload, it takes too long to spin up and spin down. Same with nuclear for safety reasons. And solar and wind you can’t spin up, you get what the weather gives you. And that’s it. 

Natural gas is our only flexible fuel source. And well we’re being flexible with it by using it right now. And that means it’s not available for the Europeans at the moment. Now, for the moment, the Europeans had been very lucky. They’re having one of the warmer winters on record even though the United States is having one of the colder ones. And that means they don’t need as much at this moment. But always remember bottom line, the infrastructure that allowed the Europeans to get to this level of storage and have this degree of supply is no longer there. So next winter is going to be far tougher.

And this winter even with high storage levels, and record low temperatures, and a lot of demand shut in, this is already the highest electricity and natural gas prices the Europeans have on record.


Get unbiased straight facts, context, and perspective!