Commentary
-
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
There’s another religious liberty case before the U.S. Supreme Court. And if you’re not careful about where you get your news, you might believe that it has something to do with Christian businessmen refusing to serve gay customers. That’s the clear implication by celebrity Jesuit priest, Father James Martin, who wrote as if the latest case is about the right to “refuse to serve people of a different religion or people who practice things that Christians disagree with.”
Such misrepresentation is typical. When Colorado baker Jack Phillips refused to participate in gay weddings, he was accused of refusing “to sell cakes to gay people.” In truth, Philips’ objection was to custom designing a cake that celebrates a same sex wedding. Phillips, a Christian doesn’t believe same-sex unions are morally equivalent to marriage, and so it would violate his conscience to force him to take part in such celebrations. In a similar way, Philips turned down cakes for Halloween or divorce parties, which also go against his religious beliefs.
The current case before the Supreme Court is similar. Laurie Smith runs her own web design company called 303 Creative. Colorado has an anti-discrimination law that would compel her to design websites for claiming beliefs she doesn’t share. She has sued to strike down this law. Again, Smith isn’t seeking the right to refuse gay customers. She would obviously make a website for any client, regardless of sexual identity or preference. It’s the content of the site where her conscience constrains her.
She won’t build a website proclaiming beliefs she holds to be wrong. The question here is about what powers the government of Colorado has. Does Colorado have the right to compel its citizens to violate their own consciences and endorse the official morality of the state government? Consider the implications if Smith loses this case and Colorado wins? Could the government force a professional ghostwriter to write a book advocating legalization of all abortion or advocating the banning of all abortion? Could the government force a baker to make a custom cake celebrating a child marriage? Could the government force a mural painter to accept a commission of a mural declaring “There is no god but Allah?” If Colorado has no tolerance for discrimination, shouldn’t an atheist painter be required to create such a celebration of Allah? If an atheist painter turned down such a project, would he be guilty of discrimination? No.
If this painter refuse to sell a painting of his to a Muslim customer, that would be discrimination. The distinction here is obvious. That it is blurred over by some media, and even by a Catholic priest whenever it comes to gay marriage, is a sign that our culture war poisons the mind.
-
Subsidizing demand won’t fix real problems
The Biden administration recently announced an initiative to cap child care copay expenses for approximately 100,000 low-income working families in the United States. Instead of paying set fees, those families will pay 7% of whatever their total income is as a copay for the government-subsidized daycare program. The program also hopes to fully cover all…
-
America’s baby bust portends tough times ahead
In 2007, Americans welcomed approximately 4.3 million babies. But following a decline in birth rates during the Great Recession, birth rates have not recovered. Over the past 15 years, the number of U.S. births has decreased annually, with the most recent 12-month period on record indicating only 3.6 million babies born. Straight Arrow News contributor…
-
Inflation is still too high and Biden is still to blame
Democrats are busy celebrating a consistently strong economy under President Biden, citing shocking GDP growth and record-low unemployment. Republicans are responding to the celebration with concerns about rising living costs, housing unaffordability, and continuing inflation. Straight Arrow News contributor Tim Carney points out that many Americans feel left behind by “Bidenomics” and argues that they…
-
College just got much pricier for American families
American colleges and universities are among the very best in the world. They are also notoriously expensive, with many graduates working for decades to pay back their college loans. But for many new students and parents hoping to help their children pay for college, tuition just became even more expensive, thanks to a new federal…
-
Hunter Biden’s tax evasion charges not the worst part of controversy
On Dec. 7, Hunter Biden was indicted on nine tax charges in California, relating to over $1.4 million in taxes owed between 2016 and 2019. While the back taxes have been settled, a potential conviction could result in a maximum 17-year prison sentence for the president’s son. On Dec. 13, House Republicans voted to formalize…
Latest Opinions
-
Aid package to Ukraine ‘not aimed at achieving victory’
-
Poll: Majority of Americans back mass deportation of undocumented immigrants
-
Trump lawyers admit some actions alleged in indictment are private, not official
-
EPA coal plant rule cuts emissions 90%, removes 17M homes worth of power
-
As 2020 election lawsuits grow, Gateway Pundit files for Chapter 11 bankruptcy
Popular Opinions
-
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.