Skip to main content
Opinion

‘Fleishman Is In Trouble’ accurately captures exhaustion of working moms

Feb 16, 2023

Share

The debate surrounding whether a mother is better off working versus staying at home with their children is decades old. Critics of working mothers argue that women should care for their children full-time, not drop them off with a nanny or daycare for someone else to manage. Critics of the stay-at-home mom might argue that her education is going to waste, she should help her husband, or worse, she’s lazy.

Working mom and Straight Arrow News contributor Jordan Reid recounts her emotional exhaustion and points to the Hulu series “Fleishman Is In Trouble” as a startlingly accurate depiction of mothers who work and parent at the same time.

I watched the Hulu show “Fleishman Is In Trouble” with particular interest given that just a few years ago — true story — the book changed my life.

On the surface, “Fleishman Is In Trouble” is a show about divorce, but it’s really about aging and ambition, and that moment that you stop and you look around, you realize you’re not waiting for your life to start…this is it. There’s also been a very interesting cultural reaction to the show. It describes with startling accuracy the midlife reckoning faced by a very particular subset of women. These are women whose on-the-surface privilege makes them very hard to describe with any real sense of empathy. Except I read the book that the show is based on shortly after getting divorced myself and by the time I turned the last page, I was like sitting there open mouth, having just learned with razor-sharp specificity what had just happened to my marriage, and my life.

So a big part of the release I felt when reading the book was the acknowledgment that you know — it’s a simple one, you would think, but not in our society — that while parenting is extremely difficult, parenting and working an outside job is more difficult. It’s almost impossible, in fact, unless those aforementioned privileges are in place, given that there is next to no structural support for parents in our society. The book holds that the condescension that suggests that stay-at-home mothers have the hardest job creates the risk of ignoring what’s happening to working mothers, which is that, frankly, they’re trapped in a system designed to break them.

I watched the Hulu show Fleischmanns in trouble with particular interests given that just a few years ago true story, the book changed my life. On the surface Fleischman is in trouble is a show about divorce, but it’s it’s really about aging and ambition. And that moment that you you stop and you look around, you realize you’re not waiting for your life to start. This is it. There’s also been a very interesting cultural reaction to the show. It describes with startling accuracy, the midlife reckoning faced by a very particular subset of women. These are women whose on the surface privilege makes them very hard to describe with any real sense of empathy. Except I read the book that the show is based on shortly after getting divorced myself. And by the time I turn the last page, I was like sitting there open mouth, having just learned with razor sharp specificity, what had just happened to my marriage, and my life. So a big part of the release I felt when reading the book was the acknowledgement that you know, it’s a simple one, you would think, but not in our society, that while parenting is extremely difficult, parenting and working an outside job is more difficult. It’s almost impossible. In fact, unless those Affer mentioned privileges are in place, given that there is next to no structural support for parents in our society. The book holds that the condescension that suggests that stay at home mothers have the you know, the hardest job creates the risk of ignoring what’s happening to working mothers, which is that, frankly, they’re trapped in a system designed to break them.

You know, I worked and I and I also picked up the kids after school. And then I spent the rest of the day ignoring half of my job or half of my family depending on who had the most pressing need of the moment. And like so many other mothers like I made the playdates and I volunteered for the pumpkin patches, and I worried about the 529 accounts and I calendar, the whatever the PTA meetings, and if something came up with, you know, a child and they had to be picked up or they were sick, I was the one switching the meeting to the zoom and just you know, doing everything at once, because I could until I couldn’t. But what I was missing with the language to explain that I was doing too much while pretending that I was not. What Fleischmann is in trouble did was the book first and then the show as well gave me the language to describe the anger that I felt the rage of having so much of my day and my mental space and everything taken up by this avalanche of work that was seemingly invisible from the outside. And much of it was self imposed or imposed by cultural expectations. But it was there Nevertheless, the show reveals to us how silly the whole thing is the school admissions and the social networking and the dinner parties and all of it while also acknowledging its emotional weight. When as a professional or a parent or a woman, is it ever good enough? The answer not just from society, but from ourselves seems to be never and it is refreshing to see right there on the screen and an acknowledgement that we all of us are completely profoundly and legitimately exhausted.

 

Video Library