Commentary
-
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
Right-wing media played a role in Buffalo shooting
JORDAN REID: I don’t often speak directly to the right. I don’t see much point in it, frankly. In my experience, the right which is less the far right and just all of the right except for strangely enough, Liz Cheney – generally responds to direct statements and questions with some combination of avoidance and gaslighting.
But I’m angry today, and I would really, really like to hear what the right has to say about the Buffalo shooting beyond offering thoughts and prayers.
The Buffalo shooting is one in a long line of racially motivated slayings based on a narrative that has been, if not explicitly supported by the right-wing community, certainly implicitly.
On May 14, a gunman opened fire at a market in a predominantly Black neighborhood of Buffalo, New York. The gunman wore military-style protective gear, and carried a semi-automatic rifle. He killed ten people, and wounded three more and 13 people in all were victims, 11 of the 13 hurt or killed in the attack were Black.
In the aftermath of shootings targeting people of color, the right likes to explain away the incidents as, for lack of a better word, blips.
It’s not because of easy access to military grade weaponry; it’s because of mental illness. It’s not because of dangerous and omnipresent racist rhetoric; it’s because of a few bad actors.
And it’s certainly not because white supremacy has been not-so-slowly, not-so-insidiously emerging from the fringes of the far right ideology into the mainstream,
Its adherents gaining steam from amplification by outlets like Fox News and host Tucker Carlson. No, it couldn’t possibly be that. Except that’s exactly what happened. And what will continue to happen, so long as these media outlets continue to use their platforms to suggest that white people are being, quote, replaced, their God-given power being co-opted by people who don’t look like them, and are therefore lesser.
Elements of the so-called Replacement Theory, apparently cited by the gunman in a “manifesto” – make frequent appearances on Tucker Carlson’s hugely popular weeknight show, albeit with terms like “the elites” or “the ruling class” substituting for, you know, Jews.
Among other claims, the theory holds that falling birthrates – due in part to feminist ideologies and increasing support for gender non-conformative individuals – and lax immigration policies are leading to the literal replacement of white people.
The theory has been cited in several mass shootings since 2018, including the synagogue shooting in Pittsburgh and the El Paso Walmart shooting. “They” want to replace “you.”
It’s a simple narrative, and an effective one, it’s commonly used by authoritarian leaders to fire people up. Think Fox News doesn’t know this? Think again.
According to an analysis in The New York Times, Carlson supported the idea that white voters are being replaced with voters from the “Third World” or immigrants in over four hundred episodes. It’s not exactly the dictionary definition of a blip.
TUCKER CARLSON: we’re sad to tell you, a horrifying amount of violence in the united states over the weekend as increasingly there is
JORDAN REID: What happened in Buffalo is horrible, it’s unthinkable and I’m sure you’ll hear people on the right say that. It’s an easy thing to say. The harder thing, as anyone who is trying to raise children to be good people knows, is to turn that harsh lens onto yourself. Except for in this case the result isn’t a playground altercation, it’s a national tragedy.
So I have to ask those on the right – not that I expect an answer – at what point does implicit sanctioning become explicit support? I’d argue that we’re there. I’d argue that We’ve been there a very long time but no matter how many times we say the quiet part out loud, the result is the same: Distraction, blame shifting, redirection, and, ultimately, nothing at all.
-
Birth control disinformation confuses young women on social media
A new social media trend may be responsible for spreading online disinformation about women’s birth control. Influencers and content creators have been publishing content that critics say is not only wrong but also potentially dangerous for young women and girls. Straight Arrow News contributor Jordan Reid confronts that disinformation and tries to clarify the pros…
-
A grim reminder of some of Trump’s most disturbing statements
While mobilizing support for U.S. Senate candidate Bernie Moreno in Ohio, presumptive Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump warned of dire consequences if he —Trump — were to lose the election. This wasn’t the first instance where the former president delivered a rally speech to threaten violence or warn of a doomsday scenario should Biden secure…
-
Racist Trump using Black voters as props
President Biden garnered significant backing from Black voters in the 2020 election, but a recent poll suggests that this support might be waning. The New York Times/Siena poll indicates support for former President Trump among Black voters has surged by 19 points over the past four years. Some analysts suggest that Biden’s strong support for…
-
US should stop providing arms to Israel
The atrocities of Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack on Israel have been well-documented, widely reported and verified by the United Nations. Since Oct. 7, however, Israeli offensives have killed around 1.5% of Gaza’s total population and displaced almost 90% of residents. With Israel facing accusations of genocide in the wake of these events, nations around the…
-
Alabama ruling destroys IVF and is not ‘pro-life’
On Friday, Feb. 16, the Alabama Supreme Court ruled frozen embryos should have some of the same legal protections as human children. The ruling has severe implications for in vitro fertilization (IVF), which freezes and uses embryos to help women become pregnant. Alabama Chief Justice Tom Parker, citing the Book of Genesis, argued that IVF…
Latest Opinions
-
Trump attends wake for fallen NYPD officer Jonathan Diller
-
A robotic future: US Army considering a platoon of steel to save lives
-
US Army upgrading Bradley IFVs with Iron Fist
-
Congress wants to give all federal inmates an ID when they leave prison
-
FTX CEO Sam Bankman-Fried gets 25 years, must pay $11 billion to victims
Popular Opinions
-
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.