Few Americans will have paid much attention to the passing of the one year anniversary of the death of Ayman al-Zawahiri. On July 31, 2022, a U.S. drone strike killed the al Qaeda leader in an upscale neighborhood in Afghanistan’s capital, Kabul.
Even when it happened, Zawahiri’s name lacked the recognition of his predecessor, Osama bin Laden, and the headlines that splashed across front pages referred to him as Al Qaeda leader, or Bin Laden successor. Fewer, still, will remark on the fact that al Qaeda still hasn’t publicly named its new leader. Does it matter? The short answer is yes and no.
Yes, it’s remarkable because this is the first time in three decades that al Qaeda has been without a public figure at its helm for a significant period of time. No, it doesn’t matter because al Qaeda’s global network continues its operations under the presumed new leader, but longtime veteran, Saif al-Adel. The long answer is more complicated.
First, the United States has always put too much emphasis on targeting individuals to weaken an organization. Even the analysis following the extensive manhunt for Osama bin Laden to carry out justice over emphasize the impact of bin Laden’s death on al Qaeda. Al Qaeda was always more than one man and bin Laden had planned for his own death. If U.S. forces had been able to kill or capture him in December 2001, in Tora Bora, bin Laden’s death would have had a greater impact. Almost 10 years later, in 2011, al Qaeda recognized Zawahiri as the new leader, about six weeks after SEAL Team Six killed bin Laden.
True, Zawahiri was far from universally liked for the position, but even those who disagreed with the decision respected it and worked within the organizational hierarchy. Zawahiri lacked bin Laden’s charisma and instead had a reputation as a dour, long winded leader. He had sold out fellow jihadist under torture in Egypt, for which some have never forgiven him. And it could be argued he mishandled the fallout with Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, leading to the split between al Qaeda and the Islamic State.
Second, Zawahiri was, according to analysis by Tricia Bacon and Elizabeth Grimm, a caretaker leader. Losing its founder bin Laden was the biggest leadership transition al Qaeda as an organization will ever experience. Al Qaeda survived under Zawahiri’s stewardship for a decade. Yes, the Islamic State splintered off and eclipsed al Qaeda on the global stage, but also, the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria is a shadow of its former self, whereas al Qaeda can point to multiple successes elsewhere, including in Afghanistan.
Yes, the United States keeps assessing al Qaeda is weaker because it cannot conduct a transnational attack like 9/11. But a close reading of al Qaeda’s own internal correspondence shows that the organization made the decision to focus on the local conflicts in 2011. To seize once in a generation opportunities to advance its cause in places like Yemen, Syria and Mali. It made mistakes but learned and evolved and is doing quite well these days. Perhaps Zawahiri wasn’t the terror boss that bin Laden was, but he did not leave al Qaeda in shambles.
Finally, we don’t know the reason why al Qaeda has not announced its new leader. The Afghan Taliban have yet to acknowledge that the US strike in Kabul killed Zawahiri, and insist that they are not harboring terrorists. Al Qaeda could be delaying any announcement on Zawahiri — including a eulogy for him — to avoid embarrassing the Taliban or endangering the sanctuary other al Qaeda leaders still have under the Taliban in Afghanistan. Saif al-Adel, the presumed leader, is also believed to be in Iran, which complicates the issue for al Qaeda. It’s hard for the organization to have a leader taking refuge in a Shia country without addressing some very difficult theological and operational questions.
Additionally, Saif al-Adel is nothing but a survivor. He’s been on the run as a jihadi for decades, described as some within the intel community as a ghost. Even his real identity was not known for a period. Saif al-Adel has rarely been featured in Al Qaeda propaganda, staying active behind the scenes. Perhaps he has opted not to change his MO, which has kept him alive all these years. From an analysis and leadership targeting perspective, it matters that al Qaeda has not named its next leader. But in terms of al Qaeda’s strength, operations and threat to the US, it’s not who sits at the top of the organization that really matters at this point. Rather, it is the leaders and members of regional affiliates who adhere to al Qaeda’s virulent ideology, have adopted its strategic doctrine, and carry on al Qaeda’s work in al Qaeda’s name who matter.
Related
Katherine Zimmerman
Fellow, American Enterprise Institute
View Video LibraryCommentary
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
Why Putin axed Shoigu
Yesterday
Peter Zeihan
New roles for Russia, North Korea, Iran in global arms trade
Monday
Peter Zeihan
Why interest rates will be higher for longer
Friday
Peter Zeihan
‘The worst it’s ever been’: Young Americans on democracy
Thursday
Dr. Frank Luntz
The impact of al-Qaeda’s missing public leadership
Aug 11, 2023
By Straight Arrow News
On July 31, 2022, al-Qaeda leader Ayman al-Zawahiri was killed during a U.S.-led airstrike in Kabul, Afghanistan. Al-Qaeda has yet to acknowledge Zawahiri’s death nor has it publicly declared a new leader to take his place.
Straight Arrow News contributor Katherine Zimmerman analyzes recent shifts in leadership within al-Qaeda and explains the significance of not having a visible figurehead at the helm of the terrorist organization.
Yes, it’s remarkable because this is the first time in three decades that al-Qaeda has been without a public figure at its helm for a significant period of time. No, it doesn’t matter because al-Qaeda’s global network continues its operations under the presumed new leader, longtime veteran, Saif al-Adel. The long answer is more complicated.
First, the United States has always put too much emphasis on targeting individuals to weaken an organization. Even the analyses following the extensive manhunt for Osama bin Laden to carry out justice overemphasize the impact of bin Laden’s death on al-Qaeda.
al-Qaeda was always more than one man and bin Laden had planned for his own death. If U.S. forces had been able to kill or capture him in December 2001, in Tora Bora, bin Laden’s death would have had a greater impact. Almost 10 years later, in 2011, al-Qaeda recognized Zawahiri as the new leader, about six weeks after SEAL Team Six killed bin Laden.
Few Americans will have paid much attention to the passing of the one year anniversary of the death of Ayman al-Zawahiri. On July 31, 2022, a U.S. drone strike killed the al Qaeda leader in an upscale neighborhood in Afghanistan’s capital, Kabul.
Even when it happened, Zawahiri’s name lacked the recognition of his predecessor, Osama bin Laden, and the headlines that splashed across front pages referred to him as Al Qaeda leader, or Bin Laden successor. Fewer, still, will remark on the fact that al Qaeda still hasn’t publicly named its new leader. Does it matter? The short answer is yes and no.
Yes, it’s remarkable because this is the first time in three decades that al Qaeda has been without a public figure at its helm for a significant period of time. No, it doesn’t matter because al Qaeda’s global network continues its operations under the presumed new leader, but longtime veteran, Saif al-Adel. The long answer is more complicated.
First, the United States has always put too much emphasis on targeting individuals to weaken an organization. Even the analysis following the extensive manhunt for Osama bin Laden to carry out justice over emphasize the impact of bin Laden’s death on al Qaeda. Al Qaeda was always more than one man and bin Laden had planned for his own death. If U.S. forces had been able to kill or capture him in December 2001, in Tora Bora, bin Laden’s death would have had a greater impact. Almost 10 years later, in 2011, al Qaeda recognized Zawahiri as the new leader, about six weeks after SEAL Team Six killed bin Laden.
True, Zawahiri was far from universally liked for the position, but even those who disagreed with the decision respected it and worked within the organizational hierarchy. Zawahiri lacked bin Laden’s charisma and instead had a reputation as a dour, long winded leader. He had sold out fellow jihadist under torture in Egypt, for which some have never forgiven him. And it could be argued he mishandled the fallout with Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, leading to the split between al Qaeda and the Islamic State.
Second, Zawahiri was, according to analysis by Tricia Bacon and Elizabeth Grimm, a caretaker leader. Losing its founder bin Laden was the biggest leadership transition al Qaeda as an organization will ever experience. Al Qaeda survived under Zawahiri’s stewardship for a decade. Yes, the Islamic State splintered off and eclipsed al Qaeda on the global stage, but also, the Islamic State in Iraq and Syria is a shadow of its former self, whereas al Qaeda can point to multiple successes elsewhere, including in Afghanistan.
Yes, the United States keeps assessing al Qaeda is weaker because it cannot conduct a transnational attack like 9/11. But a close reading of al Qaeda’s own internal correspondence shows that the organization made the decision to focus on the local conflicts in 2011. To seize once in a generation opportunities to advance its cause in places like Yemen, Syria and Mali. It made mistakes but learned and evolved and is doing quite well these days. Perhaps Zawahiri wasn’t the terror boss that bin Laden was, but he did not leave al Qaeda in shambles.
Finally, we don’t know the reason why al Qaeda has not announced its new leader. The Afghan Taliban have yet to acknowledge that the US strike in Kabul killed Zawahiri, and insist that they are not harboring terrorists. Al Qaeda could be delaying any announcement on Zawahiri — including a eulogy for him — to avoid embarrassing the Taliban or endangering the sanctuary other al Qaeda leaders still have under the Taliban in Afghanistan. Saif al-Adel, the presumed leader, is also believed to be in Iran, which complicates the issue for al Qaeda. It’s hard for the organization to have a leader taking refuge in a Shia country without addressing some very difficult theological and operational questions.
Additionally, Saif al-Adel is nothing but a survivor. He’s been on the run as a jihadi for decades, described as some within the intel community as a ghost. Even his real identity was not known for a period. Saif al-Adel has rarely been featured in Al Qaeda propaganda, staying active behind the scenes. Perhaps he has opted not to change his MO, which has kept him alive all these years. From an analysis and leadership targeting perspective, it matters that al Qaeda has not named its next leader. But in terms of al Qaeda’s strength, operations and threat to the US, it’s not who sits at the top of the organization that really matters at this point. Rather, it is the leaders and members of regional affiliates who adhere to al Qaeda’s virulent ideology, have adopted its strategic doctrine, and carry on al Qaeda’s work in al Qaeda’s name who matter.
Related
US should help Yemen fight Houthis
Recent Houthi attacks on U.S. Navy vessels and U.S. counter-strikes against Houthi targets in Yemen have triggered a foreign policy debate on how the United States should proceed and on whether a larger U.S.-Houthi conflict might be imminent. Houthi leaders say that their aim is to impede Israeli trade and shipping, even though many of…
Jan 18
US must respond to threat from Iran-backed Houthis
Last month, the commander of Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps Quds Force told the head of Hamas’ military wing that Iran will do “whatever it takes” to support them in its war with Israel. Meanwhile, the Iranian-backed Houthi rebels in Yemen intensified attacks on commercial ships in the Red Sea, prompting U.S. warships to shoot…
Dec 7
US, Israeli counterterrorism policy must adjust after Hamas attack
Revered Israeli and U.S. intelligence agencies failed to detect the signs of an imminent Hamas attack on Israeli villages near the Gaza Strip. The surprise attack was planned within Hamas’s military wing and highlights both Israel’s intelligence blind spots as well as Hamas’s use of “old-school techniques” like in-person communication. Straight Arrow News contributor Katherine…
Oct 26
US must sustain pressure against al-Qaeda
The United States and its allies have severely reduced the capacity for al-Qaeda, the terrorist group behind the 9/11 attacks, to organize or carry out any large-scale terrorist attacks against the U.S. homeland. Recent U.S. intelligence assessments suggest al-Qaeda is weaker than ever in Afghanistan, while experts and international observers continue to warn that al-Qaeda is…
Oct 12
African coups demand US policy changes
A string of recent military coups toppling governments in the African Sahel, from Guinea to Sudan, poses new risks and challenges to the United States. France, formerly a key ally in African security affairs, has also massively reduced its forces on the continent, at times being chased out by pro-Moscow forces. Straight Arrow News contributor…
Sep 15
Underreported stories from each side
White House: Biden will veto GOP bill on aid to Israel
13 sources | 0% from the left
Reuters
Arizona’s high court is allowing the attorney general 90 more days on her abortion ban strategy
45 sources | 10% from the right
Reuters
Latest Stories
More American workers cheating to pass workforce drug tests
Watch 2:04
5 hrs ago
Raskin opens probe into Trump’s $1 billion request to oil executives
Watch 1:52
5 hrs ago
China’s BYD launches hybrid truck in Mexico, US may target these vehicles
Watch 1:48
5 hrs ago
Potential TikTok buyer hopes to fundamentally change the app
Watch 2:35
5 hrs ago
How much sway does Fed’s interest rate policy have over residual inflation?
Watch 4:39
6 hrs ago
Popular Opinions
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.
Biden sees Trump jail time as sole path to reelection
10 hrs ago
Newt Gingrich
Why the United States must regulate ghost guns
10 hrs ago
Adrienne Lawrence
Unfair Biden executive order favors Democrats in November
Yesterday
Ben Weingarten
US college protests test First Amendment limits
Yesterday
Ruben Navarrette