Commentary
-
Our commentary partners will help you reach your own conclusions on complex topics.
Unlimited time off from work may be a mixed blessing
Last week, Microsoft changed its company policy to give salaried employees unlimited – or “discretionary” paid time off, allowing them to create, in their words, a more flexible work environment, where employees are able to work when and where they choose…so long as they get the work done.
This policy is an addition to “regular” time off for sick days, mental health days, jury duty, and so forth.
Which sounds great. Truly. I was the sole earner for our family when my kids were younger and my ex-husband was living part-time in another state where he went to school – and to this day, I honestly cannot wrap my mind around how mothers with inflexible jobs do it.
As an aside, I will double down forever on the very different expectations our society has when it comes to a mother’s responsibilities versus a father’s – so while this emphasis on flexibility obviously benefits everyone, I’m going to give the win to working moms.
But, as always, it’s not that simple. No, we can’t have nice things.
Because the announcement of the new policy came almost simultaneously with the company’s decision to lay off 10,000 workers, creating a situation where the remaining employees have an increased workload…and are also viscerally aware of their replaceability.
So personally, even though I was the sole earner in our household for two years while my ex-husband went to school, I found it very, very hard to take any true time off.
Because I technically *could* get everything done by working around the clock – whether I was working on actual work, or on the much less culturally-valuable work of keeping tiny humans alive – I felt intense pressure to do just that. Focus 100% of my attention on my family – forget about relaxation – when I’m on vacation? Are you kidding me? That’s not how you prove yourself.
The thing about this seemingly excellent policy is that employees are – understandably – skeptical about it. A number of studies have found that employees with an unlimited PTO policy actually took less time off, on average, than employees with a set amount of vacation days.
And the effectiveness of the policy still depends to a large extent on the specific corporate culture.
Some managers will encourage employees to take advantage of DTO, while others will telegraph their displeasure in ways that range from uncomfortable (“Jeez, this is really a crunch time for us…”) to punitive – for example, giving preferred projects to an employee who’s able to be at the office more consistently. Which swings that sexual, gender and racial bias door wiiiiide open.
When deployed correctly, discretionary time off can enhance productivity, employee retention, and trust between employees and managers. It’s a good thing, in theory. We just have to take care with its actual practice.
-
Birth control disinformation confuses young women on social media
A new social media trend may be responsible for spreading online disinformation about women’s birth control. Influencers and content creators have been publishing content that critics say is not only wrong but also potentially dangerous for young women and girls. Straight Arrow News contributor Jordan Reid confronts that disinformation and tries to clarify the pros…
-
A grim reminder of some of Trump’s most disturbing statements
While mobilizing support for U.S. Senate candidate Bernie Moreno in Ohio, presumptive Republican presidential nominee Donald Trump warned of dire consequences if he —Trump — were to lose the election. This wasn’t the first instance where the former president delivered a rally speech to threaten violence or warn of a doomsday scenario should Biden secure…
-
Racist Trump using Black voters as props
President Biden garnered significant backing from Black voters in the 2020 election, but a recent poll suggests that this support might be waning. The New York Times/Siena poll indicates support for former President Trump among Black voters has surged by 19 points over the past four years. Some analysts suggest that Biden’s strong support for…
-
US should stop providing arms to Israel
The atrocities of Hamas’ Oct. 7 attack on Israel have been well-documented, widely reported and verified by the United Nations. Since Oct. 7, however, Israeli offensives have killed around 1.5% of Gaza’s total population and displaced almost 90% of residents. With Israel facing accusations of genocide in the wake of these events, nations around the…
-
Alabama ruling destroys IVF and is not ‘pro-life’
On Friday, Feb. 16, the Alabama Supreme Court ruled frozen embryos should have some of the same legal protections as human children. The ruling has severe implications for in vitro fertilization (IVF), which freezes and uses embryos to help women become pregnant. Alabama Chief Justice Tom Parker, citing the Book of Genesis, argued that IVF…
Popular Opinions
-
In addition to the facts, we believe it’s vital to hear perspectives from all sides of the political spectrum.